An discussion on voluntary euthanasia
One woman we interviewed said that she would welcome euthanasia or assisted suicide because of what she saw on a shared ward: R: I spent a month in the hospice, … just unfortunately probably nine different ladies came into the ward and died ….
The comment concerns a point foreshadowed in a previous paragraph, but it is also linked with the remark just made about the insufficiency of an autonomous request for assistance with dying to trigger that assistance.
Hendin eds. Others maintain that individuals can be in error about whether their lives continue to be worth living cf.
Voluntary euthanasia debate
Right to die [editorial]. A woman with motor neurone disease worried about the cost of care, but also strongly favoured euthanasia because she had seen her husband suffer: R: I said the same when my lovely husband was ill, if I could have given him a tablet I would have done. It is also documented in patients suffering from obsessive compulsive disorder Care of the dying patient: the last hours or days of life. There is a need to enact a legislation to protect terminally ill patients and also medical practitioners caring for them as per the recommendation of Law Commission Report This article has been cited by other articles in PMC. Discussing the act in the Medical Journal of Australia , Professor White said eligible people could either be prescribed a voluntary assisted dying substance to administer themselves, or if they are physically incapable of doing so, a doctor could administer it. She also notes the difference made by personal involvement: I think the government has got to seriously take it on board, and I realise that it's a very dangerous subject, and it's a very dangerous area, but in the right situation it's needed …. A second contention in support of voluntary euthanasia was mentioned at the beginning of this entry, namely the importance of promoting the well-being of persons. Having said that I see all the complications of it, and people who are at a stage of illness where they can't speak for themselves, a possibility of somebody wanting to get rid of their relatives, that makes me very nervous, so although on the one hand I would like to see it to help me, I'm very hesitant about it. Ms Hackett said the organisation had determined that engaging in the political process was the best way to make MPs understand the overwhelming public support for voluntary assisted dying. Nevertheless, as we have seen, there are other circumstances in which it is highly stilted to claim, as some doctors continue to do, that they had no intention of bringing about death.
Silverman D. They believe that any competent terminally-ill patient should have the right to choose death or refuse life-saving treatment.
Evidence that will be mentioned below shows that this happens frequently in jurisdictions in which medically assisted dying has been legalized.
Kevorkian was tried and convicted in for a murder displayed on television. For the overwhelming majority of these cases, the decisions to end life were taken only after consultation between the attending doctor s and close family members, and so can legitimately be thought of as involving substituted judgements. Competence can be difficult to determine or even define. The motive for many euthanasia requests is unawareness of alternatives. Cholbi ed. Having said that I see all the complications of it, and people who are at a stage of illness where they can't speak for themselves, a possibility of somebody wanting to get rid of their relatives, that makes me very nervous, so although on the one hand I would like to see it to help me, I'm very hesitant about it. It has also clearly stated that a person attempts suicide in a depression, and hence he needs help, rather than punishment. Brinkman-Stoppelenburg, C. Many doctors in those jurisdictions where medically assisted death has been legalized and, to judge from available survey evidence, in other liberal democracies as well, see the practice of voluntary euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide as not only compatible with their professional commitments but also with their conception of the best medical care for the dying. The difference is not a matter of logical acumen; it is to be explained by reference to the importance placed on key values by the respective supporters. The hospice movement exists to deliver outstanding care to dying patients and does so. A similar legal position to that in Montana has obtained in the nation of Colombia since the late s as a result of a majority ruling by its Constitutional Court in favor of the legality of physician-assisted suicide.
based on 70 review